is holden himself guilty of being a phony

Holden is insolent towards his school, stating it’s “for the birds” (p4). He has in his head a set of behaviors that he feels are genuine and when people don't act according to them they become, in his head, a phony. When Ackley refuses to let the beat-up Holden sleep in his roommate's empty bed, Holden calls him "a real prince" and gives him a big phony handshake. Based on definition number one, Holden Caulfield is a phony because when he introduces himself to people he does not know, he gives himself a different name as well as tells them false stories of his life and past. Phonies 4: Holden himself often acquires a strained, sarcastic phoniness, either as a joke or when he is upset with someone. 4. Is Holden a phony? Of course Holden is a phony, but it is only because he is a victim of the phony culture. It's the same thing for each; he doesn't think it's all that bad or do anything about it. Get an answer for 'When is Holden Caulfield "phony" in Salinger's The Catcher in the Rye? 1. He always pretends to be something hes not and i believe he enjoys it very much. I could give fifty more examples but like I said I'm lazy and exhausted right now. However, he dearly loves his little sister, Phoebe… Holden is very judgemental about everything and everyone. Did the Algonquin's have sacred objects. False, deceiving, and not truthful. However, once again he contradicts himself by remarking that it has a “very good academic rating” (p8) and “it’s as good as most schools” (p55). Holden himself is very guilty of being a phony. Holden is not guilty of what he criticized in other people. Perhaps Holden, in denouncing the inauthenticity around him, is himself guilty of being inauthentic, a “phony.” Indeed, in the course of the novel, he runs away from responsibility, rarely thinking twice about his actions. I think this one is a little obvious. 2. Catcher in the Rye These quotes prove that phoniness is something Holden just expects and always worries about, thinking it is a normal part of society. Is Holden himself guilty of being a phony? Therefore, he is not a hypocrite. Holden believes that all adults are phony because of the fact that they take responsibility for their lives, even when things don't go your way, adults have to cope. Through Holden's negative use of the word, his hypocritical lifestyle, and his failed attempt to fix society; the word "phony" He also states, “I don’t like any shows” (p117) and, “I don’t like [the Lunts]” (p125), even though he purposely bought tickets for Sally and him to watch the Lunts. Unanswered Questions. What does it mean to be phony, according to Holden? Holden finds many people in the story guilty of violating this code of conduct. Critic Maxwell Geismer writes, “The Catcher in the Rye protests, to be sure, against both the academic and social conformity of its period, but what does it argue for?” Write an essay to explain what the book argues for. So yes, she was phony, and everything Holden said earlier remained consistent with how he acted here - he hated the people who act like phony moves are these great works of art. But, he's tame compared to Stradlater, for instance. A lot of people in this book, Holden refers to as phony. On the phony scale, though, Holden is pretty low: he is materialistic and obsessed with sex. 2. When Holden makes plans to meet Luce at a bar, he is a phony from the start, standing up at the bar to look taller so nobody will think he is a minor. Hence, him being "fake" and "not real." Holden deceives others by misrepresenting himself and acting phony. Is Holden himself guilty of being a phony? He proclaims that he hates “the movies like prison” (p29). What is a summary of The Execution by charlson Ong. Explain. I also believe the only reason he calls others out on being a phony is because he sees himself in others and doesnt approve of it. Holden is a hypocrite because he, too, puts up a façade for others, despite criticising everyone else for doing the same. To be phony it means that you are fake, that you don't act like yourself. However, he goes to the movies. What are some examples of Holden being a phony, and who does he think is a phony… Holden never says lying is phony. Holden is in fact more of a phony than the people that he accuses. Holden Caulfield of The Catcher in the Rye is critical of many things and nearly everyone with whom he has contact, including himself. 1. How does Salinger want readers to judge ideas about phoniness? 3. Holden is a hypocrite because he continually enjoys what he virulently condemns. Further confirmation that Holden is a phony. Look how he reacts to himself flattering someone, and then see how he reacts to Stradlater flattering someone.